PROBLEMATIC ISSUES OF FORENSIC MEDICAL EXAMINATION TO DETERMINE THE INDELIBILITY OF FACIAL INJURIES

Yuliya Zinenko; Olga V. Sergeeva; Dmitry A. Kharchenko

VAK Russia 5.1.4 UDC 343.98

2 more Collapse

PROBLEMATIC ISSUES OF FORENSIC MEDICAL EXAMINATION TO DETERMINE THE INDELIBILITY OF FACIAL INJURIES

Published in Forensics: yesterday, today, tomorrow · Issue 4 · Pages 104–114 · Rubric: Criminal law sciences (legal sciences)

Received: 04.09.2024 Accepted: 04.09.2024 Published: 26.12.2024

Authors

Yuliya Zinenko

Olga V. Sergeeva

Dmitry A. Kharchenko

Yuliya Zinenko

Academic degree: adjunct of architecture

Sibirskiy yuridicheski institut MVD Rossii docent · kafedra kriminalistiki · Russian Federation · Красноярск

Olga V. Sergeeva

East Siberian Institute of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia associate professor · department of forensic activities · Russian Federation · Irkutsk

Dmitry A. Kharchenko

Science rang: docent

East Siberian Branch of the Russian State University of Justice associate professor · organizacii sudebnoy i pravoohranitel'noy deyatel'nosti · Russian Federation · Irkutsk

ABSTRACT

In the article, based on the analysis of the conclusions of the experts of the KGB of the Krasnoyarsk Regional Bureau of Forensic Medical Examination, the authors consider the problems of assigning and organizing the production of forensic medical examination to determine the indelibility of facial injuries. The conducted research revealed that in 30% of cases, law enforcement officers, when appointing a forensic medical examination, along with correct questions, formulate questions to doctors by forensic medical experts that go beyond their special knowledge. According to the conclusions of the doctors of the forensic medical experts of the CCBSME, all scars located within the anatomical boundaries of the face are indelible, which cannot be agreed with. The issue of the indelibility of facial injuries is the subject of a comprehensive examination, in which, in addition to the doctors of expert commissions working in the department of complex examinations of the Bureau of Forensic Medical Examinations, a cosmetologist surgeon should be involved, which must be fixed in the new Order "On Approval of the Procedure for determining the severity of harm caused to human health."

KEYWORDS

forensic medical examination, face, facial injuries, indelibility, harm to health, indelible disfigurement of the face, methodological recommendations

Text

Text (PDF)

Read Download

1. Topilskaya, E. V. Neizdelimoe obrazirovanie litsa: priznak, nuzhdayushchiy v utrezhdenii [Indelible disfigurement of the face: a sign in need of clarification]. Kriminalist- Forensic scientist. 2019, no. 1 (26), pp. 77–82. (in Russian).

2. Plotnikov, V. S., Morozov, Y. E. Kriterii ustanovleniya neizgladimosti povrezhdeniy litsa [Criteria for establishing the indelibility of facial injuries]. Sudebnaya meditsina - Forensic medicine. 2016, vol. 2, no. 2, pp. 60–61. (in Russian).

3. Zadarnovsky, A. L., Solodun, Yu. V., Isaev, Yu. S. Ekspertnyye podkhody k ustanovleniyu neizgladimosti v sluchayakh otsenki prichinennogo vreda zdorov'yu [Expert approaches to establishing indelibility in cases of assessing harm caused to health]. Aktual'nyye voprosy sudebnoy meditsiny i ekspertnoy praktiki - Current issues of forensic medicine and expert practice. Novosibirsk. 2009. Issue 15. URL: http://journal.forens-lit.ru/node/171 (data obrashcheniya: 09/05/2024). (in Russian).

4. Zvarygin, V. Ye., Shklyayeva, S. Ye. Neizgladimoye obezobrazhivaniye litsa kak vid tyazhkogo vreda zdorov'yu: ugolovno-pravovoy i sudebno-meditsinskiy aspekty [Permanent disfigurement of the face as a type of serious harm to health: criminal-legal and forensic-medical aspects]. Vestnik udmurtskogo universiteta - Vestnik of the Udmurt University. 2015, vol. 25, issue 5, pp. 108–111. (in Russian).

5. Gordeyev, A. YU., Burtsev, A. S., D'yakov, A. N. Spornyye voprosy kvalifikatsii prichineniya tyazhkogo vreda zdorov'yu po priznaku neizgladimogo obezobrazhivaniya litsa [Controversial issues of qualification of causing grievous bodily harm on the basis of permanent disfigurement of the face]. Agrarnoye i zemel'noye pravo - Agrarian and land law: scientific. journal. 2019, no. 10 (178), pp. 119–120. (in Russian).

6. Ryabchikov, S. A. Aktual'nyye voprosy, svyazannyye s rassledovaniyem prestupleniy, prichinyayushchikh vred zdorov'yu, vsledstviye neizgladimogo obezobrazhivaniya litsa [Current issues related to the investigation of crimes causing harm to health due to permanent disfigurement of the face]. // Obshchestvo, pravo, gosudarstvennost': retrospektiva i perspektiva - Society, law, statehood: retrospective and prospect: electronic. 2020, no. 2 (2), pp. 115–119. URL: https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/aktualnye-voprosy-svyazannye-s-rassledovaniem-prestupleniy-prichinyayuschih-vred-zdorovyu-vsledstvie-neizgladimogo (data obrashcheniya: 05.09.2024). (in Russian).

7. Burmistrova, N. V., Samchuk, V. V. Ob"yektivizatsiya obezobrazhivaniya litsa pri opredelenii stepeni tyazhesti vreda, prichinennogo zdorov'yu cheloveka [Objectification of facial disfigurement in determining the severity of harm caused to human health]. Vestnik of the Academy of Law and Management - Vestnik akademii prava i upravleniya: nauch. zhurn. 2021, no. 3 (64), pp. 10– 13. (in Russian).

8. Shamatul'skiy, I. A. Neizgladimoye obezobrazhivaniye litsa kak priznak tyazhkogo vreda zdorov'yu [Indelible disfigurement of the face as a sign of serious harm to health/]. Aktual'nyye problemy rossiyskogo prava - Actual problems of Russian law. 2014, no. 8 (45), pp. 1716–1720. (in Russian).

PDF JATS XML

Chief Editor

Oleg Gribunov

gribunov@mail.ru

Deputy Editor-in-Chief

Elena Tretiakova

editor@kvsz.ru

Executive Secretary

Aleksandr Milyus

revers1985@mail.ru

Member of the Editorial Board

Zhanna A. Polyanova

1697

downloads

GOST

Zinenko Y. V., Sergeeva O. V., Kharchenko D. A. PROBLEMATIC ISSUES OF FORENSIC MEDICAL EXAMINATION TO DETERMINE THE INDELIBILITY OF FACIAL INJURIES // Forensics: yesterday, today, tomorrow. 2024. no. 4. pp. 104-114. URL: https://vestnikesiirk.ru/en/nauka/publications/article/6a9c159232807fdbab86bfda/problematic-issues-of-forensic-medical-examination-to-determine-the-indelibility-of-facial-injuries/view. (Date of access 02.11.2026).

MLA

Yuliya Zinenko, Sergeeva O. V., Kharchenko D. A.. "PROBLEMATIC ISSUES OF FORENSIC MEDICAL EXAMINATION TO DETERMINE THE INDELIBILITY OF FACIAL INJURIES." Forensics: yesterday, today, tomorrow.4 (2024): 104-114. URL: https://vestnikesiirk.ru/en/nauka/publications/article/6a9c159232807fdbab86bfda/problematic-issues-of-forensic-medical-examination-to-determine-the-indelibility-of-facial-injuries/view.

APA

Zinenko Y. V., Sergeeva O. V., Kharchenko D. A. (2024). PROBLEMATIC ISSUES OF FORENSIC MEDICAL EXAMINATION TO DETERMINE THE INDELIBILITY OF FACIAL INJURIES. Forensics: yesterday, today, tomorrow(4), 104-114. URL: https://vestnikesiirk.ru/en/nauka/publications/article/6a9c159232807fdbab86bfda/problematic-issues-of-forensic-medical-examination-to-determine-the-indelibility-of-facial-injuries/view

Chicago

Yuliya Zinenko, Sergeeva O. V., Kharchenko D. A.. "PROBLEMATIC ISSUES OF FORENSIC MEDICAL EXAMINATION TO DETERMINE THE INDELIBILITY OF FACIAL INJURIES." Forensics: yesterday, today, tomorrow, no. 4 (2024): 104-114. URL: https://vestnikesiirk.ru/en/nauka/publications/article/6a9c159232807fdbab86bfda/problematic-issues-of-forensic-medical-examination-to-determine-the-indelibility-of-facial-injuries/view.

WIKI

{{cite journal | author = Zinenko Y. V., Sergeeva O. V., Kharchenko D. A. | title = PROBLEMATIC ISSUES OF FORENSIC MEDICAL EXAMINATION TO DETERMINE THE INDELIBILITY OF FACIAL INJURIES | journal = Forensics: yesterday, today, tomorrow | year = 2024 | issue = 4 | pages = 104-114 | url = https://vestnikesiirk.ru/en/nauka/publications/article/6a9c159232807fdbab86bfda/problematic-issues-of-forensic-medical-examination-to-determine-the-indelibility-of-facial-injuries/view }}

Copy

Export: BibTeX EndNote RefMan RusMARC

PROBLEMATIC ISSUES OF FORENSIC MEDICAL EXAMINATION TO DETERMINE THE INDELIBILITY OF FACIAL INJURIES

Confirmation